Gusto Pricing: What You'll Actually Pay for Payroll
January 15, 2026
I've run payroll for small teams on a few different platforms, so I came into this one with pretty calibrated expectations. Pricing looked straightforward at first glance, four plans, base fee plus per-person. Then I actually started adding things. Benefits administration, state tax registration, the faster direct deposit option. My estimate went up about $40/month before I even got to a full headcount. The base number is real, but it's not the number you'll pay. Give yourself a proper run-through of the add-ons before you commit.
What will Gusto actually cost you?
Enter your situation below - get a real monthly estimate including add-ons, not just the base rate.
Gusto Pricing Plans at a Glance
Gusto offers four main pricing tiers. Here's what you're looking at:
| Plan | Base Price | Per Employee | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Simple | $49/month | $6/month | Small teams, single-state payroll |
| Plus | $80/month | $12/month | Growing businesses, multi-state |
| Premium | $180/month | $22/month | Larger teams needing dedicated support |
| Contractor Only | $35/month | $6/contractor | Businesses paying only contractors |
Important: Gusto increased their Simple plan base price from $40 to $49 per month as of March. Some older articles still show the old pricing.
Gusto Simple Plan ($49/month + $6/employee)
The Simple plan is designed for small businesses with straightforward payroll needs. If you're running payroll in a single state and don't need advanced HR features, this is your starting point.
What's included:
- Full-service single-state payroll
- Automated tax filings (federal, state, local)
- W-2s and 1099s
- Direct deposit (2-day or 4-day)
- Employee self-service portal
- Basic hiring and onboarding tools
- Health insurance administration
- Basic PTO policies
- Integrations with QuickBooks, Xero, and other accounting tools
- Unlimited payroll runs (no extra charges for off-cycle payrolls)
- Multiple pay rates and schedules
- Digital pay stubs with lifetime access
- Garnishment processing
- State new hire reporting
What's NOT included:
- Multi-state payroll
- Next-day direct deposit
- Time tracking
- Advanced hiring tools
- Priority support
- Workforce cost reports
- Custom admin permissions
Example cost: A 10-person team on the Simple plan pays $49 + ($6 × 10) = $109/month.
Simple Plan Add-Ons
Gusto recently introduced several add-ons for Simple plan users who need features previously only available on higher tiers:
- Time Tracking: Available as an add-on (pricing varies)
- Next-Day Pay: $15/month base + $3/person/month
- Priority Support: $8/person/month for phone and email priority access
- HR Resources: Access to certified HR experts and compliance alerts
- Performance Tools: Performance reviews and goal tracking
These add-ons give Simple plan users more flexibility to customize their experience without jumping to the Plus plan immediately.
Gusto Plus Plan ($80/month + $12/employee)
The Plus plan is Gusto's most popular option and the one most growing businesses end up on. It adds multi-state payroll capabilities, time tracking, and better hiring tools.
What's included (everything in Simple, plus):
- Multi-state payroll
- Next-day direct deposit
- Time tracking and project tracking
- Time Kiosk for employee clock-in/out
- PTO management and time-off requests
- Time off calendar syncing
- Advanced hiring and onboarding tools
- Workforce cost reports
- Custom admin permissions
- Team management tools
- Employee self-onboarding
- Custom reports
- Org chart and employee directory
- Tools for remote teams
- E-cards and celebrations
What's NOT included:
- Dedicated customer success manager
- HR resource center access
- Compliance alerts
- Priority support (available as add-on for $8/person/month)
- Performance reviews (available as add-on)
- Access to certified HR experts
Example cost: A 10-person team on the Plus plan pays $80 + ($12 × 10) = $200/month.
If you're expanding to multiple states or need time tracking built into your payroll system, Plus is worth the upgrade. The time tracking integration alone can save you from paying for a separate tool like TSheets or Homebase.
Who Should Choose the Plus Plan?
The Plus plan makes the most sense for:
- Businesses operating in multiple states
- Companies with 10-50 employees
- Teams that need integrated time tracking
- Businesses with hourly workers who clock in/out
- Growing startups that need better hiring tools
- Companies that want detailed workforce cost analysis
Gusto Premium Plan ($180/month + $22/employee)
Premium is for larger teams (think 25+ employees) that need dedicated support and advanced HR features. The per-employee cost jumps significantly, but you get white-glove service.
What's included (everything in Plus, plus):
- Dedicated customer success manager
- HR resource center with templates and workflows
- Compliance alerts for federal and state regulations
- Access to certified HR experts
- Full-service payroll migration
- Health insurance broker integration (free on Premium, $6/employee on other plans)
- R&D tax credit discounts (15% of identified credits, with Premium discounts)
- Priority support included (no additional fee)
- Performance reviews and goal tracking included
- Anonymous employee surveys
- Advanced analytics and custom reporting
- 401(k) tax credit service
Example cost: A 25-person team on the Premium plan pays $180 + ($22 × 25) = $730/month.
Premium makes sense if you're scaling quickly and don't have an in-house HR team. The dedicated support and compliance alerts can save you from costly mistakes, especially as you navigate complex HR issues like employee relations, compliance requirements, and multi-state regulations.
Premium Plan ROI
While Premium seems expensive, consider what you're getting:
- A dedicated customer success manager (worth $50,000+ if hired internally)
- Access to certified HR experts (comparable to HR consulting at $150-300/hour)
- Compliance alerts that prevent costly violations (fines can range from $1,000-$10,000+)
- Free health insurance broker integration (saves $6/employee/month)
- Full-service migration (saves 20-40 hours of work)
For companies with 25+ employees and no HR department, the Premium plan essentially provides fractional HR support at a fraction of the cost of hiring.
Gusto Contractor Only Plan ($35/month + $6/contractor)
If you only work with contractors (no W-2 employees), this plan keeps things simple and cheap.
What's included:
- Unlimited contractor payments in all 50 states
- filings and forms
- 4-day direct deposit
- Contractor self-service portal
- International contractor payments (available as add-on)
- Contractor onboarding
- Payment reminders
Promo: New users can get the first 6 months at $0/month base fee-you only pay the $6 per contractor during that period.
This plan doesn't include any employee payroll features, so if you hire even one W-2 employee, you'll need to upgrade to the Simple plan at minimum.
Contractor vs Employee: Understanding the Difference
It's crucial to correctly classify workers as contractors or employees. Misclassification can result in:
- Back taxes and penalties from the IRS
- State unemployment insurance penalties
- Workers' compensation violations
- Lawsuits from misclassified workers
Gusto's Contractor Only plan is perfect for businesses that legitimately work with contractors-freelancers, consultants, and independent professionals who control their own work methods and schedules.
Gusto Add-Ons and Hidden Costs
Here's where Gusto pricing gets tricky. The base plans look reasonable, but add-ons can quickly inflate your monthly bill by $10-30 per employee.
Common Add-Ons and Their Costs:
- Priority support + HR resources: $8/person/month (Plus plan add-on; included free on Premium)
- Health insurance broker integration: $6/eligible employee/month (free on Premium)
- Next-day direct deposit: $15/month + $3/person/month (Simple plan add-on; included on Plus and Premium)
- Health Savings Accounts (HSAs): $2.50/participant/month
- Flexible Spending Accounts (FSAs): $4/participant/month ($20 minimum)
- Dependent Care FSA (DCFSA): $4/participant/month
- Commuter benefits: $4/participant/month ($20 minimum)
- 529 College Savings: $6/participant/month ($18 minimum)
- State tax registration: Varies by state (one-time fee)
- R&D tax credits: 15% of identified credits (discounted on Premium)
- International contractor payments: Pricing varies by currency and country
Pre-Tax Benefit Account Fees
If you offer FSAs, HSAs, or commuter benefits through Gusto, there's also an annual base fee of $200 per year that applies once-even if you offer multiple benefit types. This breaks down to about $16.67/month.
Employee-specific charges then stack on top:
- HSA: $2.50/participant/month
- Health FSA: $4/participant/month (with $20/month minimum)
- Dependent Care FSA: $4/participant/month
- Commuter benefits: $4/participant/month (with $20/month minimum)
Benefits That Don't Cost Extra:
- Workers' compensation (pay-as-you-go through AP Intego)
- Health insurance administration (if Gusto is your broker)
- 401(k) setup (though there are third-party fees from the 401(k) provider)
- Unlimited payroll runs
- Off-cycle payrolls
- Year-end tax forms (W-2s, 1099s)
- New hire state reporting
- Garnishment processing
The good news: Gusto doesn't charge extra for running payroll multiple times per month or for off-cycle payments. That's a big deal if you have different pay schedules for different employees or need to process bonuses separately.
Real-World Gusto Cost Examples
Let's look at what actual businesses pay:
5-Person Startup (Simple Plan)
- Base: $49
- Per-employee: $6 × 5 = $30
- Total: $79/month
15-Person Growing Business (Plus Plan)
- Base: $80
- Per-employee: $12 × 15 = $180
- Total: $260/month
15-Person Business with Add-Ons (Plus Plan)
- Base: $80
- Per-employee: $12 × 15 = $180
- Priority support: $8 × 15 = $120
- HSAs: $2.50 × 10 participants = $25
- Total: $405/month
25-Person Company (Premium Plan with Benefits)
- Base: $180
- Per-employee: $22 × 25 = $550
- HSA annual base fee: $16.67/month
- HSAs for 20 participants: $2.50 × 20 = $50
- FSAs for 15 participants: $4 × 15 = $60
- Total: $856.67/month
See how fast it adds up? A $260/month bill can easily become $400+ when you factor in the features your team actually needs.
Understanding Your Total Cost of Ownership
When evaluating Gusto's true cost, consider these factors beyond the monthly subscription:
Time Savings
The average small business owner spends 5-10 hours per month on payroll-related tasks when doing it manually. At a conservative $50/hour value of your time, that's $250-500/month in opportunity cost. Gusto automates most of this work.
Error Prevention
Payroll tax mistakes can be expensive:
- Late payment penalties: 2-15% of unpaid taxes
- Failure to file penalties: 5% per month (up to 25%)
- Misclassification penalties: $50 per W-2 not filed
- State-level violations: $500-10,000+ depending on severity
Gusto's automated tax filing reduces these risks significantly.
Setup and Implementation
Unlike competitors like ADP and Paychex that charge setup fees ranging from $500-2,000+, Gusto offers free account setup on all plans. This is a significant upfront saving.
Contract Flexibility
Gusto operates month-to-month with no long-term contracts. You can cancel anytime without penalties. Many competitors require annual commitments, making Gusto more flexible for seasonal businesses or companies experiencing rapid change.
How Gusto Compares to Competitors
Gusto isn't the cheapest option, but it's competitive for what you get. Here's a detailed comparison:
Gusto vs ADP RUN
ADP RUN Pricing:
- Essential: $79/month + $4/employee
- Enhanced: Custom pricing
- Complete: Custom pricing
Key Differences:
- ADP has higher base costs but lower per-employee fees on entry plans
- ADP charges setup fees ($500+); Gusto doesn't
- Gusto has better user interface and customer reviews
- ADP offers more enterprise features for large companies
- Gusto integrates better with modern accounting software
Winner for small businesses: Gusto, due to transparent pricing, no setup fees, and better UX
Gusto vs QuickBooks Payroll
QuickBooks Payroll Pricing:
- Core: $50/month + $6/employee
- Premium: $85/month + $8/employee
- Elite: $125/month + $10/employee
Key Differences:
- Very similar pricing structure to Gusto
- QuickBooks has tighter integration with QuickBooks accounting (obviously)
- Gusto offers better HR features and employee benefits administration
- QuickBooks has better inventory tracking for retail
- Gusto has superior onboarding and hiring tools
Winner: Depends on your ecosystem-QuickBooks if you're heavily invested in QB, Gusto for better standalone HR
Gusto vs Rippling
Rippling Pricing:
- Custom pricing starting around $8/employee/month
- Base platform fee varies
- Must contact sales for quotes
Key Differences:
- Rippling offers more customization and IT management features
- Rippling handles international employees better
- Gusto has transparent pricing; Rippling requires sales calls
- Rippling can get very expensive with add-ons
- Gusto is simpler and easier for small businesses
Winner for small businesses: Gusto, for transparency and ease. Winner for complex needs: Rippling.
Gusto vs Paychex
Paychex Pricing:
- Custom quotes only
- Generally more expensive than Gusto
- Higher setup fees
Key Differences:
- Paychex better for enterprises (500+ employees)
- Gusto much better for small businesses
- Paychex has more PEO options
- Gusto has better technology and UX
- Paychex has longer track record (recent years)
Winner for small businesses: Gusto, hands down
Gusto vs OnPay
OnPay Pricing:
- $40/month + $6/employee
- One plan, all features included
Key Differences:
- OnPay is slightly cheaper with simpler pricing
- OnPay includes all tax filings (including local) at no extra charge
- Gusto has better HR features and benefits administration
- Gusto has more integrations
- OnPay has excellent customer support ratings
Winner: OnPay for pure payroll simplicity, Gusto for comprehensive HR
For a detailed breakdown, check out our comparisons: Gusto vs ADP, Gusto vs Paychex, Gusto vs QuickBooks Payroll, and Gusto vs Rippling.
Gusto Pricing by Business Size
Let's break down what makes sense for different company sizes:
1-5 Employees
Recommended: Simple Plan ($79-109/month)
At this size, you probably don't need multi-state payroll or advanced time tracking. The Simple plan covers all the essentials: automated payroll, tax filing, direct deposit, and basic HR tools. If you need time tracking, consider the add-on ($3/person) rather than upgrading to Plus.
6-20 Employees
Recommended: Plus Plan ($152-320/month)
Once you hit double-digit employees, the Plus plan's features become valuable. Multi-state payroll capability is crucial if you're hiring remotely. Integrated time tracking saves money on separate software. Workforce cost reports help you understand labor costs better.
21-50 Employees
Recommended: Plus or Premium ($332-1,280/month)
The decision between Plus and Premium depends on HR complexity:
- Choose Plus if you have internal HR support
- Choose Premium if you lack HR expertise and need compliance guidance
- Premium becomes cost-effective around 25-30 employees when you factor in the value of HR support
51-100 Employees
Recommended: Premium ($2,302-4,380/month)
At this size, you need the dedicated support and compliance alerts that Premium provides. You're dealing with more complex HR issues, potentially multiple states, and greater regulatory scrutiny. The dedicated customer success manager becomes invaluable.
100+ Employees
Recommended: Consider alternatives
While Gusto can handle 100+ employees, you might want to evaluate enterprise solutions like:
- ADP Workforce Now
- Paychex Flex
- Paylocity
- UKG (Ultimate Kronos Group)
These platforms offer more advanced workforce management, better analytics, and features designed for larger organizations.
Industry-Specific Gusto Pricing Considerations
Construction and Field Services
If you're in construction, you'll need:
- Plus plan minimum for time tracking with geolocation
- Project tracking to allocate labor costs
- Certified payroll reporting (Premium plan helpful)
- Workers' comp integration (included)
Expected cost: $80 base + $12/employee + workers' comp premiums
Restaurants and Hospitality
Restaurant needs include:
- Tip credit processing (included in all plans)
- Time tracking for hourly staff (Plus plan)
- Shift differential and overtime calculations
- Integration with POS systems
Expected cost: $80 base + $12/employee for proper tip management
Healthcare and Professional Services
Healthcare businesses need:
- Compliance alerts for healthcare-specific regulations (Premium)
- Multiple pay rates for different roles
- On-call and overtime tracking
- Benefits administration for competitive packages
Expected cost: $180 base + $22/employee + HSA/FSA fees
Cannabis-Related Businesses
Due to regulatory scrutiny, Gusto requires all cannabis businesses to be on the Premium plan regardless of size. This ensures access to compliance experts who understand the unique challenges of this highly regulated industry.
Required cost: $180 base + $22/employee (mandatory Premium)
Hidden Costs to Watch For
While Gusto is generally transparent, watch out for these potential surprise costs:
State Tax Registration
If you're expanding to new states, Gusto charges state-specific fees to register your business for payroll taxes. These vary by state and are one-time fees, but they can add up if you're hiring in multiple new locations.
Failed Payment Fees
If a payroll debit fails due to insufficient funds, Gusto will retry multiple times. While they don't charge a failed payment fee directly, your bank might, and employees may experience payment delays.
Paper Check Fees
Gusto is designed for direct deposit. If you need physical checks printed and mailed, there may be additional fees or you'll need to print them yourself.
International Contractor Payments
While Gusto supports international contractor payments, foreign exchange rates and international transfer fees apply. These vary by country and currency.
Workers' Compensation
While Gusto integrates with AP Intego for pay-as-you-go workers' comp, you're still paying workers' comp premiums based on your industry classification and payroll. These can range from 0.75% to 15%+ of payroll depending on industry risk.
Benefits Administration Base Fee
The $200/year base fee for offering HSAs, FSAs, or commuter benefits isn't prominently advertised but applies once you set up any of these benefits.
Credit Card Processing
If you use Gusto Wallet (their business banking product), standard transaction fees apply for credit card processing, though these are competitive with other processors.
Money-Saving Tips for Gusto Users
1. Start with Simple, Upgrade When Needed
Don't overpay for features you don't use yet. Start with the Simple plan and upgrade to Plus when you actually need multi-state payroll or time tracking.
2. Evaluate Add-Ons Carefully
Before adding priority support or HR resources at $8/person/month, calculate if upgrading to Premium makes more sense. For a 15-person team, that add-on costs $120/month. The upgrade from Plus to Premium is $100 base + $10/person = $250/month, but includes much more.
3. Use the Contractor Plan Promo
If you're just starting and only have contractors, take advantage of the 6-month $0 base fee promotion. This saves $210 upfront.
4. Bundle Benefits Strategically
Since the benefits administration base fee ($200/year) applies once regardless of how many benefit types you offer, don't hesitate to add multiple benefits if employees want them-the incremental cost is just the per-participant fee.
5. Leverage Included Features
Maximize value by using all included features:
- Run unlimited payroll (great for commission-based pay)
- Use off-cycle payrolls for bonuses (no extra charge)
- Set up multiple pay schedules (weekly, biweekly, monthly)
- Create custom PTO policies
6. Take Advantage of Gusto's Free Migration
Premium plan includes full-service payroll migration. If you're switching from another provider and have 25+ employees, the Premium plan's migration service alone can save 20-40 hours of work.
7. Check for Partner Discounts
If you work with an accountant or bookkeeper who's a Gusto partner, you might get special pricing or promotions. Ask your financial advisor if they're in Gusto's partner program.
Is Gusto Worth It?
After running payroll for a team of about 23 people over several months, here's where I landed:
It's probably worth it if:
- You're a U.S.-based small business and want payroll that doesn't require babysitting
- You want tax filing handled automatically without a separate accountant touching it
- You're integrating with QuickBooks or Xero -- that part actually worked without issues
- Month-to-month matters to you -- no contract pressure, which I appreciated
Skip it if:
- You have international employees -- the global EOR rates are steep and I'd look elsewhere first
- You need the absolute floor on gusto pricing -- OnPay undercuts it and is fine for basic needs
- You're over 100 people -- there are tools built for that scale that this isn't
- You're in construction and need union reporting -- it's not there
For most teams in the 5-50 range, the Plus tier is where it made sense for us. Time tracking, multi-state payroll, HR basics -- we used about 80% of what it offered and stopped hitting walls around week three.
Common Gusto Pricing Questions
Does Gusto charge setup fees?
No. Unlike competitors like ADP and Paychex that charge $500-2,000+ in setup fees, Gusto offers free account setup on all plans.
Can I switch plans anytime?
Yes. Gusto is month-to-month. Upgrades take effect immediately. Downgrades take effect at the beginning of your next billing cycle (first of the month).
What happens if I don't run payroll in a month?
You still pay the base plan fee, but you're only charged for active employees. If you have inactive employees or contractors you didn't pay that month, you won't be charged the per-person fee for them.
Are there long-term contracts?
No. Gusto is month-to-month and you can cancel anytime without penalties or termination fees.
How does Gusto charge for seasonal employees?
You're only charged for active employees during months they're being paid. Mark employees as inactive during off-seasons and you won't pay per-employee fees for them.
What payment methods does Gusto accept?
Gusto accepts ACH bank transfers for payroll funding and credit/debit cards for subscription fees. Most customers link a checking account for automatic withdrawals.
Does Gusto offer nonprofit discounts?
Gusto doesn't specifically advertise nonprofit pricing, but occasionally runs promotions. Contact their sales team to inquire about special pricing for 501(c)(3) organizations.
Can I get a refund if I cancel?
Gusto operates on a prepaid monthly basis. If you cancel mid-month, you'll retain access through the end of your billing period but won't receive a prorated refund for unused days.
Gusto Discounts and Promotions
Gusto occasionally runs promotions. Current and recent offers include:
- Contractor Only plan: First 6 months at $0 base fee (save $210)
- New customer discount: Run payroll by a specified date for promotional pricing
- Amazon Business partnership: Up to 50% off for first 12 months for Amazon Business customers
- Gusto Global EOR: $599/employee/month (discounted from $699) through January
- Accountant/bookkeeper referrals: Partners sometimes offer special deals through Gusto's partner program
- Seasonal promotions: Watch for deals around New Year (when businesses set up payroll) and mid-year
Check current Gusto promotions →
Understanding Gusto's Value Proposition
When I first ran payroll, I expected it to take a while. It took about six minutes. That wasn't a fluke - I've averaged maybe eight minutes per run since, which is a significant change from the two-plus hours I used to spend cross-checking everything manually.
The tax side is where I stopped worrying. Federal deposits, state withholding, unemployment insurance, local taxes where they apply - it handles the filings and I haven't had to think about it. Year-end forms showed up processed and ready. I've avoided situations that, based on past experience, would have cost real money in penalties.
The employee self-service piece actually changed how often people messaged me. Tory used to send me something every other week - a pay stub she needed, a direct deposit change, a W-4 question. That basically stopped. Employees log in, do it themselves, done. I didn't expect that to matter as much as it did, but it does.
The integrations were straightforward for the most part. I connected it to QuickBooks and it synced cleanly. I also linked it to Homebase for time tracking and the data came through without me having to reconcile anything manually. There was one mapping issue on the first sync - took me maybe fifteen minutes to sort out, and it hasn't come up since.
When you're looking at Gusto pricing, you're essentially pricing out what your time is worth, plus what a payroll mistake costs. For most small operations, that math lands in its favor pretty quickly.
What Real Users Say About Gusto Pricing
I've seen the "hidden fees surprise" thing happen with payroll tools more than I'd like. With this one, it didn't. The base fee went up on us once with not much warning, which annoyed Chad more than it annoyed me, but once we knew what we were actually paying for, the number made sense. No mystery charges showing up after month three.
The add-ons are where it starts to stack. We added two optional modules and our bill was suddenly about 30% higher than we'd budgeted. Not a scam, just something to map out before you commit.
For what we run, about 11 employees across two pay schedules, the time savings offset the cost pretty quickly. Stephanie clocked it once. We got tax filings handled in under 20 minutes that used to take most of a Friday afternoon.
Potential Drawbacks and Limitations
A few things came up during testing that are worth knowing before you commit based on gusto pricing alone.
Support was fine for straightforward stuff, but I had a contractor classification question that took about four days to fully resolve. It bounced between two reps, and the second one clearly knew more than the first. Phone support exists but you're nudged toward chat pretty consistently. If you're used to calling someone and getting it handled, that adjustment is real.
Customization is limited by design, which I mostly understand, but it did bite me on reports. I needed to slice payroll costs by department in a way the standard exports didn't support. I ended up pulling the raw data and building the breakdown myself in a spreadsheet. Not a dealbreaker, just extra steps I wasn't expecting.
The international option is expensive and narrow in terms of country coverage. Tory looked into it for two contractors we were onboarding overseas and we ended up going elsewhere. Deel handled both without much friction.
Benefits have some rigidity too, mostly around PTO configurations and non-standard deductions. Nothing I'd call broken, just less flexible than it looks at first.
When to Consider Gusto Alternatives
Gusto pricing stopped making sense for us in a few specific situations. When Derek needed to run payroll for someone overseas, it just wasn't built for that. We ended up looking at Deel and Remote, and the coverage was noticeably better. For cheaper straightforward payroll, OnPay ($40 + $6/employee) or Patriot ($17/month + $4/employee) are what I'd actually point someone toward. Enterprise teams wanting deeper customization will hit a ceiling fast. Rippling handled our software provisioning in the same flow as payroll, which saved probably three hours a week.
Making Your Decision: A Pricing Worksheet
I built a little worksheet when I was trying to figure out what we'd actually pay. Start with your headcount -- W-2s and 1099s separate, because contractors get billed differently and it catches people off guard. Then figure out how many states you're running payroll in, because that's the fork in the road that matters most for which plan makes sense.
When I ran our numbers -- 11 employees, one state, no dedicated HR -- the Simple tier came out to just under $170/month all-in. That matched what the calculator showed, which I appreciated. I added up our old provider fees plus what we were paying Stephanie's contact at the accounting firm just for payroll questions, and the switch made sense on paper before I even touched the add-ons.
The HSA and FSA fees are easy to miss. Pull those out separately before you finalize anything.
Final Thoughts
Gusto pricing landed where I expected it to after the first month -- no surprises, no setup charge, no contract I had to read twice. That part is genuinely straightforward.
For a team in the 5-50 range, the value holds up. I ran payroll for about 11 people across two states before I hit anything that felt like a real limitation, and by then I already had a feel for what tier actually made sense versus what was just upsell pressure dressed up as a feature.
I started on Simple. It was fine until the second state came into the picture -- then Plus was the obvious move, not because anyone pushed it but because the alternative was handling that manually. Premium I'd skip unless you're regularly on the phone with compliance questions. I wasn't.
The add-ons are where you have to pay attention. A few of those per-person fees stacked up faster than I expected. I went back through and cut two features I'd turned on during onboarding without really thinking about it. Saved a reasonable amount monthly for doing basically nothing.
It's not the lowest price in this category. It's also not trying to be. For what it handles without requiring much from you, the cost-to-effort ratio has been hard to argue with.
For more, see our full Gusto review and customer reviews roundup. Comparing options? Our guide to the best payroll software for small business is a good next stop.