Gusto vs Paychex: Which Payroll Service Is Right for Your Business?

Let's cut through the noise. You're comparing Gusto and Paychex because you need payroll software and don't want to overpay or pick the wrong one. Here's the real breakdown.

The quick answer: Gusto is better for small businesses under 50 employees who want transparent pricing and a clean interface. Paychex is better for companies that need more hand-holding, dedicated support reps, and the ability to scale to enterprise level.

Pricing Comparison: Gusto vs Paychex

This is where things get interesting. Gusto shows their prices. Paychex mostly doesn't.

Gusto Pricing

Gusto's pricing is transparent and published online, making it easy to budget before you commit. Here's the current breakdown:

For a 10-person team on the Simple plan, you're looking at $109/month ($49 base + $60 for employees). The Plus plan for the same team runs $200/month. With 25 employees, that's $199/month on Simple or $380/month on Plus.

The good news: Gusto is month-to-month with no contracts. You can cancel anytime, and they include unlimited payroll runs at no extra charge. They don't nickel and dime you for off-cycle payrolls.

For more detail on Gusto's costs, check out our full Gusto pricing breakdown or read our Gusto reviews.

Paychex Pricing

Paychex plays the "contact us for a quote" game, which is annoying but typical for legacy payroll providers. Here's what we know from industry reports and user feedback:

On paper, Paychex Essentials looks cheaper than Gusto Simple. For a 10-person team: $89/month vs Gusto's $109/month. But here's the catch-Paychex's entry-level plan is more limited than Gusto's, and add-ons pile up fast.

Industry data suggests Paychex's total cost typically ranges from $18-26 per employee per month when you factor in all services, which can make it more expensive than Gusto for small teams but competitive for larger organizations.

Paychex also offers PEO services for companies that want to outsource HR entirely, which reportedly runs around $140/employee per month.

Feature Comparison

Both platforms handle the basics-payroll processing, tax filing, direct deposit, W-2s and 1099s. The differences show up in the details.

Where Gusto Wins

Where Paychex Wins

Ease of Use: The User Experience Battle

This is where Gusto absolutely shines. The platform is consistently praised for its intuitive design and minimal learning curve. According to G2 reviews, Gusto scores 9.5 for ease of use compared to Paychex's 8.5.

Gusto's Interface

Gusto takes an Apple-like approach to design-hiding complexity to promote ease of use. The dashboard is clean, navigation is straightforward, and you can run payroll in just a few clicks. Users report processing payroll in an average of 8 minutes.

The mobile experience is also strong, with employees able to manage their information easily from their phones through the Gusto Wallet app.

Paychex's Interface

Paychex follows more of a Windows philosophy-showing more information upfront with lots of settings to adjust. This can be powerful for complex needs but feels cluttered for simple tasks.

The Paychex Flex platform is more modern than their legacy system, but it still has a steeper learning curve than Gusto. Users note that while it's comprehensive, it's not as intuitive for first-time users.

Customer Support Showdown

This is where things get complicated-and where Paychex's reputation takes a hit.

Gusto's Support

Gusto offers support via phone, email, and chat during business hours. On G2, Gusto earns a 9.0 rating for customer support. Users praise the responsiveness and knowledge of support staff.

However, some users note that first-tier support can be limited in knowledge, and more complex issues require escalation. The Premium plan includes priority support and a dedicated customer success manager.

Paychex's Support Reality

Here's where we need to be honest: Paychex advertises 24/7 support and dedicated reps, but customer reviews tell a different story.

On Trustpilot, Paychex has a 1.1-star rating. On Consumer Affairs, it's 1.4 stars. The common complaints:

While Paychex has an A+ BBB rating, the volume of customer complaints about service quality is concerning. Multiple users report issues with payroll errors that took months to resolve, or customer service that simply stopped responding.

The reality: Paychex's support infrastructure is impressive on paper, but execution is inconsistent. If you get a good rep, the experience can be solid. If you don't, you may face frustration.

Tax Compliance and Accuracy

Both platforms automatically calculate, file, and pay federal, state, and local payroll taxes. But there's a critical difference:

Accuracy Guarantees

Neither Gusto nor Paychex offers a tax accuracy guarantee. If either platform makes an error that results in penalties or fines, you're financially responsible for fixing it.

This is different from some competitors who offer penalty protection. However, both platforms have strong track records of tax compliance when set up correctly.

Tax Support

Paychex includes access to payroll tax specialists on higher-tier plans who can manage submissions. Gusto's Premium plan includes access to certified HR experts who can help with compliance questions.

User reports suggest that Paychex has had issues with late tax filings in some cases, resulting in IRS penalties for businesses. Always monitor your tax accounts independently, regardless of provider.

Benefits Administration: A Critical Difference

Gusto's Benefits Approach

Gusto offers benefits administration on all three plans at no additional cost. This includes:

If you use Gusto as your broker, health insurance administration is free beyond the premium costs. If you want to keep your existing broker, integration costs $6/employee per month (free on Premium plan).

Benefits administration is built directly into payroll, so all deductions happen automatically without manual intervention.

Paychex's Benefits Approach

Paychex takes benefits further with their PEO option, which provides a more comprehensive level of HR and benefits services. As the #1 401(k) provider in the country, their retirement plan integration is native and seamless-both employer and employee can access everything through a single sign-on.

However, many of Paychex's benefits features come at additional cost, even on higher-tier plans. Benefits administration is typically an add-on rather than a core feature.

Time Tracking and Workforce Management

Gusto's Time Features

Time tracking is available on Plus and Premium plans. Features include:

The integration is seamless-hours tracked flow directly into payroll calculations without manual entry.

Paychex's Time Features

Paychex offers robust time and attendance features, but they're typically add-ons that increase your monthly cost. The system supports:

For larger teams with complex scheduling needs, Paychex's time tracking capabilities are more advanced than Gusto's.

Who Should Pick Gusto

Gusto is the right choice if:

Gusto customers report saving an average of 152 hours per year on tax and compliance work after switching. The platform has a 4.6 out of 5 star average rating on G2 with over 7,000 reviews.

The main limitations: Gusto doesn't have international payroll capabilities for full-time employees (beyond contractor payments through Gusto Global), and complex HR needs can outgrow what the platform offers. It's also limited in areas like applicant tracking, learning management systems, and advanced performance management.

Try Gusto free →

Who Should Pick Paychex

Paychex makes sense if:

Paychex serves over 740,000 companies and has been in business since 1971. They have the infrastructure to handle complex, multi-state payroll for large organizations.

The downsides: User reviews consistently cite poor customer service quality, high rep turnover, pricing that spirals with add-ons, and an interface that feels dated compared to Gusto. Some users also report tax filing errors and difficulties canceling services.

The Hidden Costs to Watch

Neither platform is truly "all-inclusive." Here's what can jack up your bill:

Gusto Add-Ons

While Gusto's base pricing is transparent, benefits administration and advanced features can add up. Always clarify total costs before committing.

Paychex Add-Ons

Paychex's quote-based pricing makes it harder to predict total costs. Always get a detailed quote that lists every fee and add-on charge.

Integrations: Connecting Your Tech Stack

Gusto Integrations

Gusto integrates with over 155 third-party applications, including:

The integrations are generally smooth and require minimal setup. Data flows automatically between systems, reducing manual entry and errors.

Paychex Integrations

Paychex offers integrations with major platforms, but the quality and availability vary by plan:

Paychex's integration ecosystem is less developed than Gusto's, particularly for accounting software. However, their native features are often more robust, reducing the need for third-party tools.

Switching Payroll Providers

If you're currently using one and thinking of switching to the other, here's what to know:

Best Time to Switch

Start of a new quarter or calendar year for clean reporting. This minimizes the complexity of year-end tax forms and makes transition smoother.

Migration Assistance

What You'll Need

Contract Considerations

Gusto is month-to-month with no long-term contracts. You can cancel anytime, though you'll be billed for the current month.

Paychex contracts vary. Some customers report difficulty canceling services and being charged for features they thought they'd canceled. Read your contract carefully and get cancellation terms in writing.

Mobile Experience: Payroll on the Go

Gusto Mobile

Gusto doesn't have a dedicated employer mobile app, but the web interface is fully mobile-responsive. Employees get the Gusto Wallet app for iOS and Android, which allows them to:

G2 reviewers rate Gusto's mobile capabilities at 9.0 out of 10, praising the user-friendly interface.

Paychex Mobile

Paychex offers the Paychex Flex mobile app for both employers and employees. Features include:

The app is rated 4.8 out of 5 on both Google Play and the Apple App Store. However, some G2 reviewers note that the mobile experience lacks some administrative capabilities available on desktop (scoring 8.4 vs Gusto's 9.0).

Reporting and Analytics

Gusto Reports

Gusto offers standard reports including:

Reports are easy to generate and download as PDF or CSV. However, customization options are more limited than some competitors.

Paychex Reports

Paychex Flex Essentials includes over 160 reports covering HR and payroll metrics. Notable features:

For businesses that need deep reporting capabilities, Paychex offers more options-but navigating and generating these reports can be more complex.

HR Tools and Compliance

Gusto's HR Features

Gusto includes HR tools that work for basic needs:

For startups and small businesses, this is sufficient. However, Gusto lacks advanced HR features like applicant tracking systems, robust learning management, or employee engagement tools.

Paychex's HR Features

Paychex offers more comprehensive HR capabilities, particularly on higher tiers:

For larger organizations with complex HR needs, Paychex's depth is an advantage. However, many of these features are add-ons that increase cost.

Industry-Specific Considerations

Restaurants and Hospitality

Both platforms handle tip credits and pooled tips. Gusto's simple interface makes it easier for restaurant managers to run payroll quickly. Paychex offers more advanced scheduling features for shift workers.

Construction and Field Services

Paychex's geofencing and job costing features make it stronger for construction. Gusto's project tracking is available but less robust.

Healthcare and Professional Services

Both handle compliance well. Gusto's clean interface appeals to smaller practices. Paychex's dedicated rep model works well for busy healthcare administrators.

Nonprofits

Gusto offers specific nonprofit features and pricing. Paychex can handle complex grant accounting but may be overkill for small nonprofits.

Real User Experiences: What Customers Actually Say

Gusto User Feedback

Positive comments consistently mention:

Common complaints include:

Paychex User Feedback

Positive comments include:

Common complaints are serious:

The volume and consistency of negative customer service reviews for Paychex is concerning and should be a major consideration.

The Verdict: Making Your Decision

Here's the simple decision framework:

Pick Gusto if you're a small business (under 50 employees) that wants modern software, transparent pricing, and don't need enterprise features. It's the better choice for most companies under 50 employees, especially if you value ease of use and don't want to be locked into a contract.

Pick Paychex if you're growing fast (50+ employees), need 24/7 support availability, want everything (payroll, retirement, benefits) under one roof, or plan to scale past 100+ employees. Just be prepared for potential customer service issues and get all pricing and contract terms in writing.

For a 10-person team: Gusto wins on price, ease of use, and customer satisfaction.

For a 100-person team: Paychex becomes more competitive on pricing and offers features Gusto can't match, but customer service concerns remain.

For rapidly growing companies: Consider whether you'll outgrow Gusto in 1-2 years. If yes, Paychex's scalability might be worth the trade-offs.

Both are legitimate payroll providers that will handle your taxes correctly if set up properly. The question is which experience and price point fits your business-and whether you're willing to accept Paychex's customer service reputation in exchange for their advanced features.

Alternatives Worth Considering

Don't want to choose between Gusto and Paychex? Consider these alternatives:

For more payroll comparisons, check out our guides on Gusto vs ADP, Gusto vs QuickBooks Payroll, and our roundup of the best payroll software for small business.

Final Recommendations by Business Size

1-10 Employees

Winner: Gusto

At this size, Gusto's $109-199/month for 10 employees is competitive, and the ease of use will save you hours. Paychex's base price of $89/month looks better, but add-ons quickly close the gap-and you'll spend extra time dealing with a more complex system.

11-25 Employees

Winner: Gusto

Gusto remains the better value and experience. The Simple plan at $199/month beats most Paychex configurations when you factor in actual features included.

26-50 Employees

Winner: Gusto (barely)

This is where it gets close. If you need advanced HR features, Paychex starts making sense. If you want simplicity and good software, stick with Gusto.

51-100 Employees

Winner: Toss-up

Paychex's per-employee cost drops and features expand. But customer service issues remain. Consider both seriously and get detailed quotes.

100+ Employees

Winner: Paychex (or consider ADP)

At this scale, you need enterprise features. Gusto starts feeling cramped. Paychex has the infrastructure, though you may want to also evaluate ADP for comparison.

Implementation Timeline: What to Expect

Gusto Setup

Expect 1-2 weeks for basic setup if you're organized. You'll need to:

Gusto's interface makes this straightforward, and support is available via chat if you get stuck.

Paychex Setup

Plan for 2-4 weeks with a dedicated implementation specialist. The process is more hands-on but also more complex. Higher-tier plans include guided setup with more support.

Questions to Ask Before You Choose

Before committing to either platform, ask yourself:

  1. How many employees do I have now, and how many will I have in 2 years?
  2. Do I need 24/7 support, or are business hours sufficient?
  3. How important is ease of use vs. advanced features?
  4. What's my comfort level with technology and self-service software?
  5. Do I need PEO services, or just payroll?
  6. How many states do I operate in?
  7. What's my total budget including all add-ons?
  8. Do I need instant payments for employees?
  9. How critical are accounting integrations?
  10. Am I comfortable with the contract terms and cancellation policy?

The Bottom Line

Gusto is the better choice for most small businesses under 50 employees. It offers transparent pricing, modern software, good customer service, and all the features you actually need without the complexity.

Paychex makes sense for larger, growing companies that need advanced features and can handle the trade-off of customer service issues for enterprise capabilities. Just go in with eyes open about the potential support challenges.

Neither is perfect. Gusto lacks depth for complex needs. Paychex has serious customer service problems despite strong infrastructure. But for the majority of small businesses reading this, Gusto is the safer bet.

Ready to get started?

Try Gusto →