Printify Reviews: Is It Actually Worth It for Your POD Business?

Printify is one of the biggest names in print-on-demand. But with over 10 million users and thousands of reviews scattered across the internet, it's hard to know what to believe. Some people swear by it. Others have horror stories about print quality and customer service.

I've dug through hundreds of user reviews on Trustpilot, Shopify App Store, G2, and various forums to give you the real picture. Here's what you need to know before committing to Printify for your business.

The Quick Verdict on Printify

Printify holds a solid 4.6/5 rating on Trustpilot based on over 6,800 reviews. On the Shopify App Store, it scores 4.8/5 from 7,400+ reviews. These are genuinely good scores for a POD platform.

But here's the thing: Printify's quality depends heavily on which print provider you choose. Some users get flawless products every time. Others report inconsistent prints, off-center designs, and shipping delays. The platform is essentially a middleman connecting you to dozens of different printing facilities—and not all facilities are created equal.

Bottom line: Printify is a solid choice if you're willing to do your homework on print providers and order samples before selling. If you want guaranteed consistency without the extra legwork, you might want to look at alternatives like Printful (which now owns Printify after their merger).

Try Printify Free →

What People Actually Love About Printify

The Free Plan is Genuinely Useful

Unlike some competitors that gate important features, Printify's free plan includes everything you need to start: unlimited product designs, integrations with major ecommerce platforms, a mockup generator, and up to 5 stores per account. You only pay for products when you make a sale—no monthly fees, no upfront costs.

This is a major advantage for beginners testing the waters with print-on-demand.

Massive Product Selection

Printify offers over 1,000 customizable products. We're talking way beyond the standard t-shirts and mugs. You can sell embroidered caps, jewelry, pet products, kitchen accessories, sports bags, swimwear, and even custom supplements and coffee. If you're looking to build a unique product line, Printify gives you more options than most competitors.

Easy to Use Interface

Users consistently praise how intuitive the platform is. You can create your first product in about five minutes: choose a blank item, upload your design, pick a print provider, and publish to your store. The dashboard is clean and the profit margin calculator helps you price products correctly.

Transparent Pricing

When you select a product, you see exactly how much it costs from each print provider, including shipping estimates. There are no hidden fees or surprise charges. This transparency makes it easy to calculate your profit margins before committing to a product.

For a full breakdown of costs, check out our Printify pricing guide.

The Problems You'll Actually Run Into

Inconsistent Print Quality

This is the most common complaint, and it's a real issue. Since Printify works with dozens of different print providers, the quality of your products depends entirely on which facility fulfills your order. Users report that some providers deliver excellent results while others produce off-center prints, dull colors, or cracked designs after washing.

The solution? Always order samples before selling a product. Check the provider ratings within Printify (aim for 9+ stars), and read reviews from other sellers in Printify communities.

Shipping Can Be Slow and Expensive

Printify shows production time estimates (usually 2-7 business days), but actual delivery depends on the print provider and shipping destination. For US orders, expect 2-8 days total. International shipping can take 3-30 days.

Some users report shipping costs that eat into their margins, especially for heavier items or international orders. You'll need to factor this into your pricing strategy.

Customer Support is Hit-or-Miss

Printify offers 24/7 live chat and email support—no phone support unless you're on the Enterprise plan. During normal times, response times are decent (an hour or two). But during high-volume periods like Q4, users report waiting 24+ hours for responses.

Some users praise the support team for quick resolutions. Others complain about being passed between departments without getting answers, especially for complex issues involving print providers.

Embroidery Can Be Frustrating

If you're planning to sell embroidered products, proceed with caution. Multiple users on the Shopify App Store report issues with embroidery digitization failing without clear explanations. One user had identical designs approved for one order and rejected for another, with no useful feedback from support.

Printify Pricing Breakdown

Printify offers three plans:

Real example of Premium savings: A custom hoodie that costs $17.09 on the free plan drops to $13.74 on Premium. Sell 50 hoodies a month and you're saving $167.50—the $29 fee pays for itself in about a week.

Printify vs. The Competition

Thinking about alternatives? Here's how Printify stacks up:

Printify vs. Printful: Printful has in-house fulfillment, which means more consistent quality but higher prices. Printify gives you more print provider options and lower base costs, but quality varies. Fun fact: Printful and Printify merged in late 2024, so expect more integration between the platforms. Read our detailed Printify vs Printful comparison.

Printify vs. Gelato: Gelato focuses on global printing with facilities in more countries, which can mean faster international shipping. Printify has a larger product selection. Both have similar pricing structures.

Printify vs. Redbubble: Different models entirely. Redbubble is a marketplace where they handle everything but you have less control over branding and margins. Printify requires your own store but gives you full control. Printify typically offers better profit margins if you're willing to do the work.

Who Should Use Printify?

Printify is a good fit if you:

You might want to skip Printify if you:

Tips for Success with Printify

Based on what successful sellers report, here are the keys to making Printify work:

  1. Always order samples first. Don't sell anything you haven't held in your hands. This is non-negotiable.
  2. Choose providers with 9+ star ratings. Printify shows ratings based on quality, speed, and reliability. Stick with the top-rated options.
  3. Read provider-specific reviews. Join Printify communities on Facebook and Reddit to see which providers other sellers recommend for specific products.
  4. Set realistic shipping expectations. Be upfront with customers about delivery times, especially during holidays.
  5. Consider Premium once you're selling regularly. If you're making 10-20+ sales per month, the 20% discount will more than cover the subscription cost.

Is Printify Legit?

Yes, Printify is 100% legit. Founded in 2015, they've processed nearly 60 million orders and serve merchants in over 200 countries. They're headquartered in Latvia and have a legitimate business operation. For more details, see our article: Is Printify legit?

The complaints you see online are mostly about quality inconsistency and support issues—real problems, but not signs of a scam. Every major POD platform has similar complaints at scale.

Final Verdict: Should You Use Printify?

Printify is one of the best print-on-demand platforms available, especially for sellers who want low costs and maximum product variety. The free plan is genuinely useful, the interface is easy to use, and the Premium plan offers real value for growing businesses.

The catch is that you're responsible for vetting print providers and ensuring quality. If you're willing to put in that work, Printify can be a profitable platform for your business. If you want a more hands-off experience with guaranteed quality, you'll pay more for it elsewhere.

Ready to give it a shot? You can start for free and see if it works for your business.

Start Your Free Printify Account →