Is Printify Worth It? An Honest Take on Costs, Margins, and Quality

You're thinking about starting a print-on-demand business, or maybe you're already selling and wondering if Printify is the right platform. The short answer: for most sellers, Printify is worth it — but only if you understand what you're getting into and how to work around its weaknesses.

I've dug into the real numbers, user reviews, and platform limitations so you can make an informed decision. Let's get into it.

What Printify Actually Costs

Printify has three pricing tiers, and the good news is you can start without spending a dime:

The Premium plan math is simple: if you're doing 10-20+ sales per month, the 20% discount on products will more than cover the $29 subscription fee. For more detailed pricing breakdown, check out our full Printify pricing guide.

The Hidden Costs You Need to Know

Here's where many new sellers get tripped up. The base product price is just the start. You also need to factor in:

A popular Bella+Canvas 3001 t-shirt starts around $7.95-$9.11 depending on print provider (lower with Premium). But once you add shipping and marketplace fees, you need to price carefully to maintain healthy margins.

Realistic Profit Margins on Printify

Printify officially recommends targeting a 40% profit margin on your products. Based on user reports and industry data, actual margins typically range from 10% to 60% depending on your niche, pricing strategy, and how well you manage costs.

One seller running Etsy stores since 2020 reported maintaining around 50% profit margins with relatively low ongoing work required. That's a realistic target if you:

For a deeper comparison with Printify's main competitor, read our Printify vs Printful comparison.

The Quality Problem: Printify's Biggest Weakness

Here's the thing nobody tells you upfront: Printify doesn't actually print anything. They're a middleman connecting you to 140+ print providers worldwide. This creates flexibility but also inconsistency.

Printify holds a 4-star rating on Trustpilot with over 6,800 reviews and scores 4.7/5 on the Shopify App Store. Most users are satisfied. But complaints about print quality problems appear more frequently among Printify users than some competitors like Printful, which handles printing in-house.

The frustrating part? Provider ratings in Printify are applied uniformly across all products. A printer might nail mugs and stickers but struggle with t-shirts — and you won't know that from their overall score.

Common Complaints from Real Users

Some sellers on review sites report frustration with the claims process, where Printify asks for photos, SKU numbers, and sizes rather than quickly resolving problems. That said, Printify does offer a 30-day window to report quality issues with photo/video evidence for investigation.

What Printify Does Well

Despite the quality variability, Printify has real advantages:

The free plan is genuinely functional for beginners. You can create unlimited designs and connect multiple stores without paying Printify anything until orders come in.

Who Printify Is (and Isn't) For

Printify Makes Sense If You:

Consider Alternatives If You:

If consistent quality matters more than price, Printful is the standard alternative — they handle everything in-house but charge more. For a detailed breakdown, see our Printify vs Printful comparison.

How to Actually Succeed with Printify

If you decide to use Printify, here's how to avoid the common pitfalls:

  1. Always order samples first. This is non-negotiable. Test every product with every provider you plan to use.
  2. Research providers thoroughly. Check Printify's subreddit and Facebook groups for real feedback on specific printers for specific products.
  3. Choose providers close to your customers. This reduces shipping costs and delivery times.
  4. Don't just pick the cheapest option. Consider production speed, reliability ratings, and shipping costs together.
  5. Upgrade to Premium when it makes sense. Once you're hitting 10-20 sales per month, the math works in your favor.
  6. Set realistic delivery expectations. Production time is separate from shipping time — communicate this clearly to customers.
  7. Track your true costs. Build a spreadsheet that includes product cost, shipping, marketplace fees, and any other expenses.

The Bottom Line: Is Printify Worth It?

Yes, Printify is worth it for most print-on-demand sellers — especially beginners and those prioritizing low costs. The free plan lets you start with zero risk, and the platform offers more product variety at lower prices than most competitors.

But it's not a hands-off solution. You need to invest time in choosing good print providers, ordering samples, and managing customer expectations around shipping times. The quality inconsistency is real, and customer support can be frustrating when issues arise.

If you're willing to put in that work, Printify offers a legitimate path to building a profitable POD business with realistic 30-50% margins. Just go in with open eyes.

Try Printify Free →

Related Resources